Notice: Due to recent changes to EU legislation sales to these countries is currently unavailable. Please accept our apologies.
> Forums
Reply
12
> General > Proxies and Alternatives > Egypt revolts against Persia
TOPIC: Egypt revolts against Persia
PM DuncanWB
Standard User
Posts: 59
Egypt revolts against Persia
DuncanWB
24th Oct 2022 09:55:57

Back in the day, when I studied the subject, I gathered that Egypt always struggled with raising good quality cavalry because local conditions were not well suited to maintaining large herds of horses due to shortage of year-round forage. The hardier breeds of horses available locally were generally small, and better suited to hauling chariots than being ridden.  Probably why they used chariots for longer than their neighbours.

I'm sure that by the time of the revolt (and into the Ptolemaic period and later) local horse breeders were improving stocks as best they could, and increasing numbers of cavalry could be fielded. But the year-round forage problem meant they were never able to compete for numbers with rivals who could source horses from Anatolian or Iranian stock. 


Altera Restat

PM kaiww
Standard User
Posts: 31
Egypt revolts against Persia
kaiww
25th Oct 2022 05:01:48

@Duncan

Intresting point, i will asume for my project that Egypt did develop a cavalry but that it was still an uncommen unit to see.

By the way, could one source of horses not have been Nubia? I do not know if they had better conditions to raise horses in Nubia but it was already a place to get mercenarys and i think i have read somwere that the Nubians did develop a decent cavalry.

And my project is coming along very well and i will start building detailed army list, i will then upload them, so more expirenced wargames can tell me all the things i got wrong ;D.


"My God, Mr. Bragg, you have quarreled with every officer in the army, and now you are quarreling with yourself."

PM DuncanWB
Standard User
Posts: 59
Egypt revolts against Persia
DuncanWB
26th Oct 2022 06:49:42

If you think about the landscape of southern Egypt and northern Sudan, similar issues would arise of a shortage of year-round quality grazing land. There is certainly some, and Nubia, Kush and Meroe would extend the scope for sourcing both horses and forage. But from what I remember the horses used for their cavalry were still smaller breeds than those in use by heavy Persian cavalry. But the hardiness of the smaller breeds would give them the advantage when campaigning on Egyptian territory, whereas Persian cavalry horses might suffer.    


Altera Restat

PM kaiww
Standard User
Posts: 31
Egypt revolts against Persia
kaiww
29th Oct 2022 07:02:03

@DuncanWB

you see i know nothing.......call me John Snow ;)

I never thought about the landscape and suitablity for horses down there. Thanks for the informations Duncan it helps a lot. :)

 

 


"My God, Mr. Bragg, you have quarreled with every officer in the army, and now you are quarreling with yourself."

12
 

LATEST FORUM POSTS

Formatting has returned! by jwsleser
24th Sep 2026

Insertion Tools by peter
24th Sep 2026

Formatting has returned! by peter
24th Sep 2026

Formatting has returned! by David Kay
23rd Sep 2026

Insertion Tools by David Kay
23rd Sep 2026

UPCOMING SHOWS

The Other Partizan (Newark Showground, Newark)
11th Oct 2026

Fiasco (Royal Armouries, Leeds)
25th Oct 2026

Warfare (Farnborough Exhibition Centre)
14th Nov 2026-15th Nov 2026

Battleground (Stockton on Tees)
29th Nov 2026

LATEST RELEASES

WBT49 -  Churchill NA75WBT49
Churchill NA75

WGP88 - JgPzVI FerdinandWGP88
JgPzVI Ferdinand

WGP53V - PzVG Panther veteransWGP53V
PzVG Panther veterans

WGG06 - sIG33 auf berge HetzerWGG06
sIG33 auf berge Hetzer

WGG03 - StuIG33 auf PzIIIWGG03
StuIG33 auf PzIII