Notice: Due to issues with the processing of VAT on deliveries to the EU a limit has been put in place, restricting orders to a maximum of £135. We apologise for any inconvenience this causes.
> Forums
Reply
1
> General > Proxies and Alternatives > Boshin War Project - Using Franco-Prussian War figures as proxies
TOPIC: Boshin War Project - Using Franco-Prussian War figures as proxies
PM Berggeit
Standard User
Posts: 45
Boshin War Project - Using Franco-Prussian War figures as proxies
Berggeit
18th Nov 2022 04:09:27

I am planning a Boshin War project and I think the French around 1870 are my best bet at proxies for the westernized units. As I basically know nothing about the 19th century military uniforms nor about the French during the Franco-Prussian war. Could someone help me explain the difference between the Imperial and the Republic infantry in tunic. From what I can see the difference is that the imperial have a slash for webbing and decorative pieces on their shoulders while the republican infantry have crossed webbing and no decorative pieces on their shoulders. Is that correct? 

Additionally, does someone have a close up picture from the Prussian Infantry? They might be suitable for infantry of the Satsuma domain, who used tall conical hats. 


Email dourpuritan PM dourpuritan
Standard User
Posts: 1072
Boshin War Project - Using Franco-Prussian War figures as proxies
dourpuritan
18th Nov 2022 04:42:57

The Republican infantry in tunic do not have the French greatcoat or the shoulder epaulettes. I kn ow absolutely nothing about the Boshin War, so do not know which would be the most useful French figure to use.  Is it in Japan? The Prussian 1870 infantry wear the spiked leather pickelhaub helmet.


A little goes a long way

PM Berggeit
Standard User
Posts: 45
Boshin War Project - Using Franco-Prussian War figures as proxies
Berggeit
18th Nov 2022 05:23:00

Ah then the Republican infantry is more fitting. 

The Boshin war was an Civil War in Japan, 1868-69 between the Shogun and Pro-Shogun clans and Anti-Western/Pro-Imperial clans. 

Each clan had their own army and in various states of modernasation. There wasn't much uniformality in terms of gear and uniforms. It went from traditional to modern/Western. The republican infantry in tunics seem a good fit to represent Denshutai, French trained troops of the Shogun. 
For the moder traditional armed troops I plan on using Zouaves. Formed for western rifles and skirmish for the traditional matchlock guns. 


PM ChrisBBB
Standard User
Posts: 132
Boshin War Project - Using Franco-Prussian War figures as proxies
ChrisBBB
21st Nov 2022 11:05:02

A suggestion for the conical hats: the relatively smoother-surfaced pith helmets on British colonial infantry might be better than spikey 1870 Prussian pickelhaubes.

Nice project. (Myself, I am more interested in the later Satsuma Rebellion, specifically because the battle of Tabaruzaka is big enough to merit a "Bloody Big Battles!" scenario some time.)


1
 

LATEST FORUM POSTS

Bloody big battles basing by dourpuritan
1st May 2024

Gettysburg reenacted (solo) by ironass
1st May 2024

Gettysburg reenacted (solo) by jon1066
1st May 2024

Vanquish show 6mm game by Estarriol
1st May 2024

Gettysburg reenacted (solo) by ironass
30th Apr 2024

UPCOMING SHOWS

LATEST RELEASES

HCNOMAD - Hail Caesar Arab Nomad ArmyHCNOMAD
Hail Caesar Arab Nomad Army

GNF11 - Ottoman Turkish FlagsGNF11
Ottoman Turkish Flags

AMN04 - Martu/Amorite ArchersAMN04
Martu/Amorite Archers

AMN03 - Martu/Amorite JavelinmenAMN03
Martu/Amorite Javelinmen

AMN02 - Guti Arab Javelinmen, shieldAMN02
Guti Arab Javelinmen, shield