> Forums
Reply
1
> Rules > Polemos Rules > Polemos ECW rules
TOPIC: Polemos ECW rules
PM steve rowe
Standard User
Posts: 1
Polemos ECW rules
steve rowe
27th Jun 2022 03:09:22

Reading the system rules for Ranged attack (the Ranged shooting example) and have a problem with how the combat results have been calculated.

According to the example on page 23 Lord Taylor's 4 base Royalist brigade advance towards the 3 base brigade of Sir Anthony Cullen. In reply, Cullen' s bases R1, R2 and R3 fire at bases C1, C2, C3 and C4. Combat values, die rolls and tables adjustments are all added to give the final results. This is the point at which I have the problem;

IF the bases R1, R2 and R3 are using Offensive fire and get results of

(R1 difference of +4)

(R2 difference of +3)

(R3 differences of -1 and 0) 

How can the Defending bases suffer a -4 adjustment for fire over 1BD distance?, when the table clearly states the Defending unit adjustment for this fire should be 0.

 

Am I reading something wrong or does this entire Ranged fire example need to be rewritten to make sense?.

 


PM Whirlwind
Standard User
Posts: 500
Polemos ECW rules
Whirlwind
28th Jun 2022 06:17:36

 

"Am I reading something wrong or does this entire Ranged fire example need to be rewritten to make sense?."

Yes, it needs to be re-written.


1
 

LATEST FORUM POSTS

Polemos SPQR - Officers and Generals by G_Hamilton
17th Nov 2026

Civil War or 19th century mortar by SKling
4th Nov 2026

It’s just a Fantasy. by Mort53
3rd Nov 2026

It’s just a Fantasy. by Brad1971
3rd Nov 2026

Warfare show, Farnborough UK, 14 Nov 2026 by ChrisBBB
30th Oct 2026

UPCOMING SHOWS

Battleground (Stockton on Tees)
29th Nov 2026

LATEST RELEASES

GWBOXH - Gallic Wars campaign Boxed set GWBOXH
Gallic Wars campaign Boxed set

cover - cover


civer - civer


gwcovrr - gwcovrr


map - map